MAKAN

Moving Archaeological Knowledge Away from Neo-colonialism

 Partecipanti

Mappa

+-

Leaflet | Map data © OpenStreetMap contributors, CC-BY-SA, Imagery © Mapbox

 Word cloud

Esplora la "nuvola delle parole (Word Cloud) per avere un'idea di massima del progetto.

 Obiettivo del progetto (Objective)

'The history of archaeology is tightly intertwined with colonialism. The archaeological rediscovery of ancient Middle Eastern civilizations, in particular, coincided, from the mid-19th century, with the process of colonial appropriation of the Ottoman Empire. For over two centuries the Middle East has been a resource both for ancient materials, enriching major Western collections, and for historical antecedents, and has itself remained disciplinarily excluded from the recovery of its own Past. Well after the acquisition of formal national independence by many countries colonial archaeology seems to have been followed, not by national, but by neo-colonial archaeological practices. In Egyptian Archaeology colonial rule resulted in a rigid exclusion of the local community, recreated by each subsequent generation of archaeologists, of all nationalities including Egyptian. The challenge of giving the local communities a primary role in developing and disseminating archaeological knowledge is of the outmost importance for the decolonization of Egyptology. Their involvement would end a traditional exclusion of local communities from their own Past and the Western control of knowledge. The MAKAN project objectives are: -to construct a self-critical history of Egyptian Archaeology, from the study of its formative phase and of so-called Neo-colonial Archaeology -to evaluate current strategies and proposing new approaches to the issue of the Decolonization of Egyptology, along the path of the World Archaeological Congress -the analysis of possible venues for the local community re-appropriation of its own Past, investigating whether local and distant museums can be accessible spaces for community expression and exchange -to implement a multi-site ethnography, designed from Petrie Museum proposed links and collection provenances, addressed to the production of a holistic evaluation report including guidelines for ethics in Egyptian Archaeology projects'

Introduzione (Teaser)

Western societies have access to collections excavated in the Middle East while local cultures have ironically been excluded from their own past. Thankfully, new approaches have been created towards the decolonisation of Egyptology.

Descrizione progetto (Article)

Archaeology and colonialism have long been intertwined. Starting from the mid-19th century, this holds true concerning the Middle East. This region of the world has been a resource for ancient materials enriching western collections for over two centuries, while simultaneously excluded from the praxis of recovering its own heritage and history. The EU-funded project 'Moving archaeological knowledge away from neo-colonialism' (MAKAN) investigated the issue in Egypt and Sudan.

Such disparity is of a complex nature. It spans from viewing local workmen as unskilled labourers needing constant supervision by non-locals in charge. Beyond that there is a lack of local interest in the past that is greatly overlooked. Funding of western projects in Middle Eastern countries far exceeds what the countries can afford for their own projects, leading to a kind of economic neo-colonialism within archaeology. Finally, the reports providing studies and site data are rarely published in the host country's language.

Despite all the studies conducted on intercultural interactions on Middle East excavations and their impact on the lives and opinions of local inhabitants, topics relating to the politics of archaeology are rarely found in prominent journals. This is particularly true for Egyptology. Furthermore, objects from local territory may be housed far off in western countries and even local museums may not be accessible by locals.

MAKAN examined the formative phase of Egyptian archaeology. Direct access to various archives helped create a self-critical history of the discipline. This led to a better understanding of the dynamics of knowledge production.

Ultimately, the aim was to create a productive means for raising awareness of the importance for local communities to reconnect with their past. Looking at local and distant museums as spaces for community expression and exchange was also part of the work.

A vital part of the MAKAN project was participation in an exhibition project comprised of 200 objects on display from the Petrie Museum at the Egyptian Cultural and Educational Bureau (ECEB) in London. Egyptians living and working in London were directly involved, and this complemented the workshop held in Egypt in December 2012. As a result of such events, more insight has been gathered on how to approach the experience of local societies in both Egypt and Sudan. This opens a means for further discussions, reflections and guidelines for Nile Valley archaeology in the future.